Internet sales tax would be bad for NM - Albuquerque Journal

Internet sales tax would be bad for NM

Taxpayers in the Land of Enchantment are lucky to have Susana Martinez as their governor.

New Mexico’s Democratic-controlled Legislature recently sent her a tax-hiking budget bill – House Bill 202 – to which she quickly responded, “I will never allow lawmakers to raise taxes on our families to bail out big government.”

Gov. Martinez is likely to veto HB 202 in the coming days, and for good reason. From the gas tax increase to the car excise tax increase, the various cash-grabbing measures in HB 202 would be detrimental to the economic health of the state.

Of the many anti-growth provisions included in HB 202, the internet sales tax is among the worst. This provision would force out-of-state businesses to collect and remit gross receipts taxes to New Mexico – including local option taxes.

Though New Mexico residents may feel removed from this tax on out-of-state businesses, they shouldn’t. The internet sales taxes would have a number of negative consequences in store for them as well.

While the out-of-state businesses would be doing the collecting and remitting, New Mexico consumers would be the ones carrying the financial burden. Businesses subject to HB 202’s internet sales tax would pass the associated costs on to customers in the form of higher prices. Or, New Mexico consumers may be left with fewer choices, as out-of-state retailers may determine the complexities and liabilities of the internet sales tax are too great to justify doing business in New Mexico.

HB 202’s internet sales tax could also stifle investment and job growth in New Mexico. Time and time again, business owners and site selectors explain that state tax structures are among the primary considerations of companies seeking out locations to launch or expand their operations. As such, piling an internet sales tax – which sends out hostile, anti-innovation signals to not only tech companies, but business across all industries – on top of New Mexico’s already-unimpressive tax code would be counterproductive.

In addition to chasing off businesses and increasing consumer costs, HB 202’s internet sales tax is also likely to result in hard-earned taxpayer dollars being wasted on costly legal challenges. The Commerce Clause of United States Constitution only requires businesses to collect and remit taxes on sales in states where they have a sufficient “nexus,” or connection. In a 1992 Supreme Court Case, Quill v. North Dakota, the court ruled that “nexus” sufficient for taxation means physical presence inside state borders.

States that have attempted to flout the court’s ruling by implementing their own “nexus” standards, such as Alabama, Illinois, New York and South Dakota, typically end up wasting scarce taxpayer resources on expensive lawsuits. Why would anyone assume New Mexico’s fate would be different?

Unfortunately, lawmakers often mask all of these costs and consequences with alleged concerns about “fairness,” falsely claiming the internet sales tax would “level the tax playing field” between brick-and-mortar shops and online retailers. But concerns of an unlevel playing when it comes to tax are illogical.

The employers and employees of businesses with no physical presence in New Mexico would neither use nor benefit from any public services, programs or projects funded by the state’s gross receipts tax, so there is no justification for lawmakers targeting them as a source of revenue. Indeed, the internet sales tax is just another way for money-hungry lawmakers to rake in more hard-earned tax dollars instead of focusing on the spending side of the ledger.

New Mexico’s spending has drastically outpaced the growth of both population and inflation. But, until lawmakers acknowledge this fact and start cutting back on bloated government, New Mexico’s economy will continue heading down the drain.

Fortunately for taxpayers, Gov. Martinez remains committed to a pro-growth agenda and is likely to protect them from HB 202, as well as any other tax the Legislature tries to impose on the state.

Margaret Mire manages state affairs at Americans for Tax Reform.

 

Home » Opinion » Guest Columns » Internet sales tax would be bad for NM


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
Future Fund celebrates 25 years of grant-making
From the newspaper
Celebrating 25 years this October, Albuquerque ... Celebrating 25 years this October, Albuquerque Community Foundation's Future Fund acquaints yo ...
2
Utility pole access is key to broadband on tribal ...
From the newspaper
Unfortunately required permitting process can be ... Unfortunately required permitting process can be complicated and opaque
3
NMBSA's $50M pitch aims to grow economy
From the newspaper
New Mexico has an abundance of ... New Mexico has an abundance of world-class scientists and innovators developing cutting-edge solutio ...
4
A man lost his leg after being run over ...
ABQnews Seeker
Lawsuit claims forklift operator, store did ... Lawsuit claims forklift operator, store did not take proper precautions
5
The annual Rio Grande Arts and Crafts Festival Holiday ...
ABQnews Seeker
In its 22nd year, the holiday ... In its 22nd year, the holiday show featured the work of 165 artists
6
End of the line: Why some New Mexicans may ...
ABQnews Seeker
NM Medicaid enrollees warned: Yearly requalifications ... NM Medicaid enrollees warned: Yearly requalifications on horizon again
7
University of New Mexico's plan for massive development project ...
ABQnews Seeker
Plan to use tax money for ... Plan to use tax money for site's development under scrutiny
8
Jemez Pueblo native starts a business focused on healthy ...
Columnists
I'm not a vegetarian, much less ... I'm not a vegetarian, much less a vegan, so talking about food in those terms is a bit like le ...
9
GivingTuesday: Every act of generosity counts
Columnists
GivingTuesday is a global movement unleashing ... GivingTuesday is a global movement unleashing the power of radical generosity. GivingTuesday was cre ...