Teachers unions, APS slam NM's education plan - Albuquerque Journal

Teachers unions, APS slam NM’s education plan

New Mexico has submitted a federally required plan to the U.S. Department of Education that will guide policy for years, though teachers unions and Albuquerque Public Schools were critical of its mandates.

The state Public Education Department’s Every Student Succeeds Act plan maintains controversial policies like school grades, PARCC testing and teacher evaluations, with a few tweaks. For instance, by 2020, high school students will have to score higher than now on PARCC to demonstrate competency for graduation.

School grades will also include new measures like science scores and English-language learner student progress by the beginning of the 2018-19 school year.

Secretary of Education Hanna Skandera touted the plan Tuesday as an important step forward that was designed with extensive input from educators, families and community leaders statewide.

Skandera and her staff crafted the ESSA document after holding 25 public forums in six cities across the state last fall. New Mexico First, a nonpartisan policy organization, collaborated with PED to organize and facilitate the series of meetings, which attracted 663 participants.

“We didn’t talk at these other than to kick it off and say, ‘We’re here to listen,’ ” Skandera told the Journal editorial board Tuesday. “This was an incredible opportunity to hear from folks and make change based on what matters in our community.”

Public Education Secretary Hanna Skandera
Public Education Secretary Hanna Skandera

Skandera said the PED is a national leader on listening to “teacher voice,” and education chiefs in other states have been calling to ask about her approach.

But teachers unions argue that Skandera has not heard their concerns.

Betty Patterson, National Education Association New Mexico president, attended ESSA forums in Santa Fe and Albuquerque, and said she was uncomfortable with the process.

“Simply stated, the process was not as neutral as they claim and keep working hard to make it appear it was,” she said in an emailed statement. “Many of the concerns I heard during the two meetings I went to don’t appear to have been addressed. The group doing the sessions was said to be unbiased, but most sessions were run by PED cheerleaders and all sessions were attended by teachers on the advisory committees.”

Albuquerque Public Schools, six other districts and 15 charter schools held their own forums in partnership with the University of New Mexico Center for Education Policy Research and Learning Alliance New Mexico in an attempt to influence the ESSA plan. The UNM center compiled feedback from more than 4,000 participants and submitted it to PED.

Last week, Carrie Robin Brunder, APS director of government affairs and policy, told Board of Education members the PED’s forums received different feedback than the district’s.

“Most noticeably is the disconnect between the two reports regarding social and emotional well-being of students and the need for more individualized learning experiences for both teachers and students,” APS administrators wrote in a response to the state ESSA plan. “APS believes the ESSA plan should highlight these themes and seize the opportunity to work on new innovative models to shift the paradigm in our schools.”

The UNM center also reported that its forum participants wanted more limited testing, hands-on learning and individualized assessments.

Asked about the UNM CEPR report, Skandera said she “worked hard to incorporate feedback only under the presupposition that all students can learn.”

“Students deserve that we have high expectations for them,” she said.

Ellen Bernstein, Albuquerque Teachers Federation president, said she felt Skandera’s response “marginalizes” those who don’t agree with her educational philosophy.

Bernstein was critical of the state’s ESSA plan overall, arguing that it includes ideas recycled from the federal policies it is replacing: No Child Left Behind and Race to the Top.

“The teachers I talk to are interested in professional support, not PED punishments,” she said.

Critics also expressed concern about funding.

Charles Goodmacher, NEA New Mexico government and media relations director, said many of the specifics in the ESSA plan are “unattainable so long as our Legislature and the governor fail to sufficiently fund our public schools.”

PED is asking districts to meet the new targets by the 2019-20 school year, including increasing the graduation rate to 80 percent, up from the current 71 percent. At the same time, half of students must show math and reading proficiency by earning a 4 or 5 score on PARCC. In 2016, when a score of 3 was acceptable, proficiency rates hovered around 20 percent to 30 percent.

APS administrators are worried about reaching the goals.

Brunder told the APS board that it could be difficult for the district to raise the bar on PARCC and graduation rates at the same time.

Several board members said at the meeting they were disappointed with the ESSA plan.

Board member Barbara Petersen said the plan is almost harder to stomach than recent budget cuts because she believes the policies are not good for students and teachers.

“This is undermining the vision of the district,” she said. “I have such a headache listening to this right now, I can barely talk.”

Home » News » New Mexico News » Teachers unions, APS slam NM’s education plan

Insert Question Legislature form in Legis only stories

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

ABQjournal can get you answers in all pages


Questions about the Legislature?
Albuquerque Journal can get you answers
Email addresses are used solely for verification and to speed the verification process for repeat questioners.
National Puppy Day: Here are the top dog names ...
ABQnews Seeker
It's National Puppy Day this week; ... It's National Puppy Day this week; send us your best pup photos for a special Journal photo feature. Bonus points if your dog's name ...
Grammer: What Rick Pitino to St. John's means for ...
ABQnews Seeker
Odds & ends around UNM hoops, ... Odds & ends around UNM hoops, including the status of next season's Iona game and an update on the first Lobo in the transfer ...
Volcano Vista's Alter commits to the University of the ...
ABQnews Seeker
Volcano Vista's 6-foot-9 Sean Alter, who ... Volcano Vista's 6-foot-9 Sean Alter, who was integral as the Hawks won their second straight Class 5A state basketball championship earlier this month, has ...
Kids connect with nature at ABQ BioPark’s spring break ...
ABQnews Seeker
Nearly 50 elementary school kids are ... Nearly 50 elementary school kids are spending all or some of the five days of their spring break visiting the attractions that make up ...
Prep notes: Schools making quick use of APS out-of-state ...
ABQnews Seeker
When Albuquerque Public Schools made it ... When Albuquerque Public Schools made it known they were opening the door for out-of-state travel for its spring sports programs this year, the La ...
Albuquerque Metro Championship finals delayed indefinitely
ABQnews Seeker
Neither the metro softball final between ... Neither the metro softball final between Volcano Vista and La Cueva, nor the baseball final at Rio Rancho between the Rams and La Cueva, ...
Photos: Rio Rancho take on La Cueva during the ...
ABQnews Seeker
Supreme Court seems split in Navajo Nation water rights ...
ABQnews Seeker
WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court seemed split ... WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court seemed split Monday as it weighed a dispute involving the federal government and the Navajo Nation's quest for water from ...
Wind and scattered rainfall in store for Albuquerque this ...
ABQnews Seeker
Travellers should beware of dicey road ... Travellers should beware of dicey road conditions, particularly on the plains.