UNM Foundation refuses to release requested documents - Albuquerque Journal

UNM Foundation refuses to release requested documents

The University of New Mexico Foundation says it is not a public body and that sharing certain documents could threaten donor privacy and possibly violate donors’ First Amendment rights, according to a court filing in a public records lawsuit.

In response to a case brought by journalist Daniel Libit, the foundation argues it is not subject to the state’s Inspection of Public Records Act and that releasing documents Libit requested “would violate the free speech and free association rights” of donors, as well as their First Amendment rights “to remain anonymous.”

Libit, who runs the website nmfishbowl.com, in March filed a complaint in state District Court in Albuquerque. His suit contends the foundation “is a creature of the University and is substantially controlled by the University. Libit’s complaint asks the court to declare the foundation a public body subject to the state’s public records law and also order it to release documents related to WisePies’ naming rights deal for UNM’s basketball arena.

The UNM Foundation “exists solely to serve UNM by raising and managing private investments,” according to its media guide. It operated within the university for nearly 30 years but became a standalone organization in 2008.

Its court filing denies it “plays a public role or is a public body which creates and maintains public records subject to IPRA.”

A foundation spokeswoman said she could not comment on pending litigation. She referred questions to attorney Randy Bartell of Montgomery & Andrews, who is representing the foundation in the case.

Bartell reiterated the stance that the foundation is not a public body and spoke to the foundation’s First Amendment defense.

“Under certain circumstances, yes, there absolutely is” a First Amendment right to remain anonymous, he said, citing the Supreme Court’s decision in the Citizens United election spending case.

“This isn’t political, but some of the discussion around the First Amendment in that case, and other related cases, does have applications (here),” he said. “This case does have an interesting feature to it, where you’ve got the right of the public to know what’s going on with public money, but the right of people who want to give money to remain anonymous. Where is that line going to get drawn?”

Libit called the foundation’s First Amendment defense “specious,” and his attorney says it should not serve as the basis for keeping foundation records private.

“That’s a discussion for the foundation to have with its donors – what legal processes are there for donors who wish to remain anonymous to remain anonymous,” said Nicholas Hart of the Albuquerque firm Freedman Boyd Hollander Goldberg Urias & Ward. “I don’t believe that the foundation self-declaring itself as a private entity not subject to IPRA is the legal way to achieve that goal.”

While UNM last week announced it intended to terminate its WisePies deal to make way for another donor, the lawsuit will proceed.

“WisePies is the subject matter, not the underlying basis of the lawsuit, which is about their refusal to turn over public records,” Libit said in an email.

Home » News » Albuquerque News » UNM Foundation refuses to release requested documents


Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email yourstory@abqjournal.com

taboola desktop

1
County closes Carlito Springs, bans open fires
ABQnews Seeker
Ban will remain in place until ... Ban will remain in place until further notice
2
Hidden fuels still a threat in northern blazes
ABQnews Seeker
Weather shifts to critical fire Weather shifts to critical fire
3
Voters to decide two Dems for District Court posts
2022 election
Winners of Division 10, 16 will ... Winners of Division 10, 16 will likely run unopposed in November
4
Two first-generation Americans face off in CD2 Democratic primary
2022 election
Vasquez, Patel vie for chance to ... Vasquez, Patel vie for chance to run against Yvette Herrell, the state's only Republican member of Congress
5
Shooting by Chaves County sheriff's deputies raises questions
ABQnews Seeker
Lapel camera footage shows deputies opening ... Lapel camera footage shows deputies opening fire on man
6
Guns found at ABQ, RR high schools
ABQnews Seeker
No injuries were reported as two ... No injuries were reported as two students face charges
7
APD arrests son in father's death, IDs unrelated homicide ...
ABQnews Seeker
Police looking into a possible homicide ... Police looking into a possible homicide Tuesday afternoon at a mobile home park on West Central
8
House race features past, present representatives
2022 election
Ex-legislator takes on Dem incumbent in ... Ex-legislator takes on Dem incumbent in primary
9
Feds: Ohio man plotted visit to Texas to kill ...
ABQnews Seeker
An Iraqi man who came to ... An Iraqi man who came to the United States two years ago and applied for asylum hatched a plot to assassinate former President George ...