Rep. Pearce says health care bill an improvement - Albuquerque Journal

Rep. Pearce says health care bill an improvement

Michael Coleman logoWhen House Republicans first tried to replace Obamacare in March, Rep. Steve Pearce – a member of the conservative House Freedom Caucus – didn’t support the legislation. But on Thursday, after weeks of additional negotiating, the House approved the American Health Care Act with Pearce’s support. The new bill, which now heads to the Senate, passed by a very narrow 217-213 vote – so Pearce’s support was crucial.

Democrats – including those representing New Mexico – characterized the bill as a heartless proposal that gives tax breaks to the wealthy while stripping poor people of health care options. The headline on a scathing Washington Post editorial Friday summed up the legislation in three words: “Betrayal, carelessness and hypocrisy.” The editorial said the legislation was hastily concocted without the benefit of a Congressional Budget Office analysis of its costs or how many Americans would lose their coverage under Obamacare. The bill also offered no iron-clad protections for those with pre-existing conditions, the editorial noted, and would allow states to choose whether their insurers can opt out of coverage for pre-existing conditions.

In an interview with the Journal editorial board Friday, Pearce called characterizations of the Republican bill as draconian or heartless “totally misplaced.”

“We got a much better bill,” Pearce said in comparing the previous House GOP bill to that passed Thursday. “It still has deep flaws – you could find a dozen reasons to vote against it. But with Obamacare, we are in an absolute free-fall. I’m here representing a group of people on the lower end of the economic spectrum, and they are just struggling to make ends meet.”

“If the Senate passed the bill today I think people in New Mexico would see a significant reduction in their rates,” Pearce added. “At the end of the day, I think that’s what people care about.”

Throughout the debate, the Republican congressman has fixated on something called “essential health benefits” under the Affordable Care Act. The 10 such essential health benefits, which include vaccines, maternity and mental health care, were mandated as part of insurance coverage under the Affordable Care Act. But Pearce argues that a young man without a family shouldn’t be expected to help underwrite maternity care and the requirement he do so drives up costs. Under the version the House passed Thursday, states would be able to create their own list of essential health benefits that could result in less required coverage.

“The treatment of the essential health benefits gives me deep pause … essential health benefits are (currently) required in every plan in the country,” he said. “The young healthy people are opting out because the costs are going up.”

Pearce also said he hoped the Senate would implement “more stringent work requirements” for those who receive Medicaid. House Speaker Paul Ryan put into the bill that passed Thursday a provision letting states impose work requirements on people who enroll in Medicaid. Critics contend such a requirement would punish people already struggling financially. Pearce said those who can’t take care of themselves would still be protected, “but increasingly, there are people who are able to work who just don’t,” he said. “We should have some modest work requirement.”

The Congressional Budget Office estimates the bill would cut federal spending on Medicaid by 25 percent by 2026 compared to current law, shifting the burden to cash-strapped states and potentially leaving fewer poor people covered.

The Republican congressman also discussed Trump’s proposed border wall. He said while he wants to “secure the border” he still opposes a wall along the U.S.-Mexican border. But he stopped short of a vow to vote against any money to pay for it.

“I don’t think I ever steadfastly said I’d vote against anything with (the money) in there,” Pearce said. “I want to secure the border, but this isn’t going to be very effective.” He also said he sensed Trump may be softening his resolve to build an actual wall and may eventually settle for some other compromise on enhanced border security, which could include fencing, drones, additional manpower, etc. “I hear his language evolving and that of the people he’s got working for him,” Pearce said.

As for the president’s job performance after 100 days and a week in office, Pearce gave Trump a thumbs up.

“I think he’s grown in that capacity … grown in stature,” Pearce said. “Overall he’s done almost exactly what he said he would do, whether you agree with him or disagree with him, but finding someone who will actually do that is stunning.

“With Bush and Obama I never saw this level of engagement. This is what I think we need – a strong, steady hand,” Pearce added. ” I’d rate him pretty high.”

E-mail: Go to to submit a letter to the editor.


Home » Opinion » Columnists » Rep. Pearce says health care bill an improvement

Insert Question Legislature form in Legis only stories

Albuquerque Journal and its reporters are committed to telling the stories of our community.

• Do you have a question you want someone to try to answer for you? Do you have a bright spot you want to share?
   We want to hear from you. Please email

taboola desktop

ABQjournal can get you answers in all pages


Questions about the Legislature?
Albuquerque Journal can get you answers
Email addresses are used solely for verification and to speed the verification process for repeat questioners.
Financial checkup time! As we near the halfway point ...
WE GET YOU THE ANSWERS: As ... WE GET YOU THE ANSWERS: As we near the halfway point in 2023, it’s time to evaluate your fiscal health
Financial checkup time! As we near the halfway point ...
WE GET YOU THE ANSWERS: As ... WE GET YOU THE ANSWERS: As we near the halfway point in 2023, it’s time to evaluate your fiscal health
How to help reduce light pollution and enjoy the ...
SOLUTIONS: There are things we can ... SOLUTIONS: There are things we can do to reduce light pollution and promote dark skies.
Don’t be a sucker for love, failed-bank plea or ...
SCAM WATCH: A new study reports ... SCAM WATCH: A new study reports that the state ranked No. 2 in the nation for the percentage rise in money lost to romance ...
Happy Mother’s Day! From humble origins to big business, ...
OPINION: Originally conceived as a personal ... OPINION: Originally conceived as a personal celebration between mothers and families, it was not long before florists, card companies and other retailers capitalized on ...
Journal Cartoonist John Trever's recent work
John Trever tackles Albuquerque and New ... John Trever tackles Albuquerque and New Mexico issues with his signature cartoons this and every Sunday.
NM needs a special (climate) session now!
OPINION: New Mexico has geothermal resources ... OPINION: New Mexico has geothermal resources that if developed can replace coal and natural gas electrical generation.